Dispeling some discipline thoughts

Pack a lunch and grab some coffee, I’m going to take a bit of a walk today. I’m going to start with a bit of whimsy.

I wish, sometimes and among other wishes, that Focused Power in the Discipline tree were 5 instead of 2 talent points. This would make it an almost perfect match for the Shadow Focus with up to 10 percent + spellhit. Of course, it couldn’t be a smooth change. After all, it sits at a higher tier than the shadow version, and for good reason. That’s because of the change it also makes to Mass Dispel.

Now, if the 5 points were allowed, the modification Mass Dispel would have to change as well. After all, reducing MD by half a second a step – when it already starts at 1.5 seconds for cast – is obviously absurd. And frankly, the current 2/2 always tempts me when I consider a Disc spec. Oh, it’s not the most critical talent, but…

Have you looked at Mass Dispel? Seriously? See, from what I’ve seen it’s not so frequently used (outside arenas), and yet… It is worse than the normal dispel in two ways. First, it’s 1.5 seconds instead of instant – no running while casting. Second, it “only” removes one opponent’s buff or debuff on a friendly instead of two. On the other hand…

AoE dispel with a radius the same size as that of Circle of Healing. And while it’ll only remove one spell per person per cast, it can affect five friendlies and five foes all at the same time. And the kicker – it can dispel things the normal cannot. Most people know of the fact it’ll remove a paladin’s bubble. It also – not as well known – removes Ice Block. And Banish. Now, it has some serious problems. In addition to the 1.5 second cast it’s mana intensive (1/3 of your BASE mana) – comparable in cost to Greater Heal. And it randomly selects the targets in the area and THEN checks to dispel. And – with a slight twist – randomly selects the (de)buff to dispel. Oh – and paladins with the correct talent have a 30% chance of resisting the dispel (which can in turn be countered). Oh – and always beware of Unstable Affliction — which goes “Boom”on the dispel caster if it’s dispeled. (As an aside, this can be terribly ugly if you’re fighting a warlock (especially multiple) plus pally team in an arena. Not paying attention can lead to impressive suicides.)

Over in PVE, it can remove a surprising number of things – the difficulty is simply remembering to use it (and again having the time usually means getting it down to half a second cast time with the focus talent). Almost all slows (for example but not only those of Aran and Heroic Ikiss). Mobs that seem to frost nova everyone – or otherwise apply dots to everyone (the Maiden, for example, in Kara). Mobs that self-buff can frequently be frustrated here as well.

Of course, if you’re Disc with an eye to this spell, you’ve probably also looked hard at Absolution. The 15% gained from 3/3 of this talent can make a large difference given the mana cost of this spell – but I’ll note it’s more useful in PVP than PVE as three talent points is a lot UNLESS you know you’ll dispel, mass dispel, and cure or abolish disease with any frequency.

Mass Dispel is in many ways a spell like Circle of Healing or Lightwell. The uses exist – and for a dedicated practitioner they’re a lot more common than most people would believe, and further those uses can be surprisingly useful to the raid or party. I cannot advocate it as a “must have” any more than I can Lightwell or Circle of Healing — in other words, I do advocate looking hard at it as an option, but it’s not the Must Have of shadow focus for shadow priests. If you ARE planning to use the spell with frequency, then the disc talent Focused Power 2/2 is highly recommended choice.

~ by Kirk on October 26, 2007.

3 Responses to “Dispeling some discipline thoughts”

  1. Slightly OT, but something I’ve been thinking about a bit.

    Do you think a full Discipline priest healer could work (after the amazing change to Pain Suppression in 2.3)?

    PS seems so good and so flexible – you can “perma-fade” an over-eager DPS class (particularly Shaman and Fury Warrs that can’t drop threat any other way), and you are the Pali-Tank’s Shield Wall that they don’t have (the threat loss shouldn’t hurt a Tankadin).

    PI is a nice pickup too, and is actually really good for healing when used on a Druid (that uses it in a maintained Rolling Lifebloom), and it can be given to a lock or mage in a DPS race/enrage timer situation.

    You bring Imp DS and Inspiration uptime, as well. Improved PWS could be a nice buffer if used properly (i.e., full health, full rage situations)

    You don’t have the throughput of a holy priest (with Spiritual and Empowered Healing), but your mana pool is quite a lot larger, and you bring a heck of a lot more DPS to burn down trash faster (FoW + Searing Light + 4% to hit with Smite).

    Don’t know if it’s worthy or not, but it might be fun to think about and/or try.

  2. Jabari, I’m bring up a second priest (I pretty much promised the guild I’d quit tinkering with my main) to test things like this. It’s something I want to try.

  3. I’ve Currently got my priest specced up 41/20/0 for raids/heroic/solo and it works well.
    For Heroic you can do a healing or DPS role as good as any other.
    For raids you may find your heals a bit underpowered to provide a main healer role. You can however dish out as much damage as a shadow priest. So providing your guild will let you try it you can spend most of your time doing damage and off heal when needed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: